After a car hits you on a bike in New York City, the no-fault insurance (PIP) on that car pays your medical costs and lost earnings first, whoever caused the accident. A personal injury case against the driver for pain and suffering requires a serious injury.
Of the 4,403 bicycle injuries NYC DOT recorded on city roads in 2025, 3,536 came in accidents with a motor vehicle, the accidents this guide covers.
Who Pays First After a Bicycle Accident in New York City
The no-fault insurer of the vehicle that hit you pays your medical expenses and lost wages first, whoever caused the accident.
- The no-fault limit is $50,000 per person for medical expenses, lost earnings and other necessary costs.
- Lost earnings are paid at 80 percent, up to $2,000 a month for up to three years.
- Workers’ compensation, Social Security disability or state disability benefits recovered or recoverable for the same injuries reduce what no-fault pays.
- An at-fault motorist’s bodily injury liability insurance pays beyond no-fault, with a limit as low as $25,000 per person.
- Supplementary uninsured/underinsured motorist insurance on your or a household relative’s policy may pay once the motorist’s limits run out, if lower than that policy’s own.
If the Driver Fled or Had No Insurance
When the driver fled or had no insurance, your own or a household relative’s auto policy pays the no-fault. The Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation (MVAIC) pays when there is no such policy, covering New York State residents and bicyclists from places that give New Yorkers similar protection.
After a hit-and-run, the MVAIC law requires a police report within 24 hours and a sworn notice to MVAIC within 90 days.
What Compensation Can You Get After a Bike Accident?
- A case against the driver recovers economic damages above the basic economic loss no-fault covers, and compensation for pain and suffering only for a serious injury. There is no formula for the compensation beyond no-fault, which can include:
- Medical and rehabilitation costs above basic economic loss, including future care.
- Lost earnings above the no-fault cap, and lost earning capacity.
- Pain, suffering and emotional distress from your injuries, the non-economic damages.
New York State’s serious injury categories are death, dismemberment, significant disfigurement, fractures and loss of a fetus. They include permanent loss of use of a body organ, member, function or system, a permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member, and a significant limitation of use of a body function or system. For lawsuits commenced on or after May 26, 2026, missing your usual activities for 90 of the first 180 days no longer counts.
How a Bike Damage Claim Works in New York City
No-fault never pays for the bike, helmet or gear, because it covers only personal injury losses. The bike damage claim goes to the at-fault motorist’s property damage liability coverage, with a $10,000 minimum. The compensation depends on proof such as:
- Photos of the bike and each damaged part.
- Repair estimates, since damages are the reasonable repair cost, capped at the bike’s value before the accident.
- A receipt showing what the bike cost.
- For a totaled bike, comparable listings or a shop valuation showing its market value just before the accident, since damages are that value less salvage.
Small Claims Court hears a matter up to $10,000 if the motorist lives, works or does business in the city (court act).
How Fault Works in a New York City Bicycle Accident Claim
The action against the motorist depends on proving the motorist’s negligence, while the insurer may put part of the fault on you to lower your compensation or end the case.
For car-crash injury lawsuits commenced on or after May 26, 2026, you recover nothing if your fault exceeds the defendants’ combined fault, but a smaller share reduces your recovery. No-fault benefits ignore your share of fault. A bike damage claim is reduced by your share, never barred.
Steps to File a Bicycle Accident Claim in New York City
The bicycle accident claim is built on a police report, medical records, photos and notice to each insurer.
- Report the accident to the police at the scene, and note the officer’s name and precinct.
- Get medical care the same day, even when injuries seem minor, then follow the treatment plan and request the records.
- Take photos of the scene, the vehicle and its plate, the bike and your injuries before anything is moved.
- Get the driver’s name, plate and insurance information, and witnesses’ names and phone numbers.
- Keep the bike, helmet and gear unrepaired until they are photographed or inspected, since repair erases the evidence.
- Notify the insurer of the vehicle that hit you in writing of the no-fault claim within 30 days, and note the claim number. Any SUM claim needs written notice to the SUM insurer as soon as practicable
- Request the police report (NYPD form MV-104P) from the precinct within 30 days, or after that from the DMV on form MV-198C.
- Keep every medical bill, receipt and pay stub showing lost wages.
In BALG’s analysis of the NYC Comptroller’s fiscal 2023 claims data, the City took a median 3.52 years from the incident to settle an injury claim over a City vehicle. A road-defect claim took a median 5.65 years.
Deadlines for a Bicycle Accident Claim in New York City
The 30-day no-fault notice runs out first unless a clear and reasonable written justification excuses the delay, although after a hit-and-run the 24-hour police report comes sooner.
|
Step |
Deadline (from the crash unless noted) |
|
No-fault notice to the car’s insurer |
30 days |
|
Proof of claim, medical bills |
45 days after each treatment |
|
Proof of lost earnings, expenses |
90 days after each loss |
|
Police report, hit-and-run |
24 hours |
|
Sworn MVAIC notice, hit-and-run |
90 days |
|
City notice of claim (vehicle or road defect) |
90 days |
|
Lawsuit against the City |
1 year and 90 days |
|
Lawsuit against a private driver (statute of limitations) |
3 years |
A road-defect case also needs proof that the City knew of the defect in writing before the crash, separate from the 90-day notice of claim. Without written notice of the defect or of an earlier injury it caused, or the City’s written acknowledgment, followed by 15 days without a repair, the case cannot go forward.
In BALG’s analysis of the NYC Comptroller’s fiscal 2023 claims data, the NYC government took a median 3.52 years from the incident to settle an injury matter over a City vehicle. A road-defect action took a median 5.65 years.
Why Is the Insurance Company Stalling Your Bicycle Accident Claim?
The insurance company often stalls your claim to pay less through a recorded statement, slow handling, an early low offer or a technical denial, according to the attorneys at BALG.
- Anything said in a recorded statement to the adjuster can be used to value or dispute it.
- In the cases BALG handles, the first settlement offer is usually made before treatment shows the full extent of the injuries.
- A no-fault denial can rest on late notice, missing documentation or an exclusion, while a liability denial can rest on disputed fault.
- No-fault insurers must pay or deny within 30 days of receiving complete proof of claim, including any requested verification.
- Overdue benefits earn 2 percent monthly interest.
When Cyclists Need a Lawyer for a Bicycle Accident Claim
A bicycle accident lawyer is worth the call, rather than handling the matter yourself, when the injury may be serious, the insurance company disputes fault, several policies apply, or the compensation stalls or is denied.
The lawyer gathers evidence of fault, documents your injuries and damages, looks for every applicable policy including household uninsured motorist coverage, and weighs each settlement offer against future compensation.
Without a serious injury the insurer owes no compensation for pain and suffering, and your share of fault can cost you the lawsuit.
Talk to a Lawyer About Your New York City Bicycle Accident Claim
If a car hit you on a bike, send us the police report, your photos and each claim number through the contact page. A bicycle accident lawyer who rides will review them in a free consultation and tell you which compensation and deadlines apply. If a City vehicle or road defect caused the accident, a late notice of claim to the City can end the case. We’re cyclists as well as injury attorneys, and bicycle accident cases are the only cases we take.
We handle bicycle accident cases on a contingency fee basis. You pay no attorney’s fee unless we recover compensation for you.